Skip to main content
  • Three jars of homemade nut butter side by side
  • Three jars of nut butter lined up side by side
  • Nut butter - 3 easy recipes – photo 3
  • Nussbutter - 3 einfache Varianten
  • Nut butter - 3 easy recipes – photo 5
  • Nut butter - 3 easy recipes – photo 6
  • Nut butter with apple wedges, stuffed dates and a pancake, plated
  • Nut butter - 3 easy recipes – photo 8
  • Nut butter - 3 easy recipes – photo 9
  • Nut butter - 3 easy recipes – photo 10

22 JANUARY 2018

Nut butter - 3 easy recipes

By Verena Frei

This post is also available in: deutsch

Jump to recipe

Last updated 8 July 2026

Total
30 min

Hello lovelies, have you ever tried to make your own nut butter? Next to nut milks (you can find my easy recipe for almond milk here) it's one of the things I make on a regular basis and that are so easy to prepare and taste much better than store bought. I used to love the store bought peanut butter (yes the sugary version), but that was before I started making my own and realizing how much more intense the taste is and that an addition of sugar is not necessary at all.

Three jars of nut butter lined up side by side

And after trying cashew butter for the first time, I had to tell my beloved peanut butter: sorry, but I have someone new. I might be slightly addicted to cashew butter, I just love that velvety flavor - so divine. And yes also cashew butter is super easy to make. Today I like to share 3 different recipes with you: a peanut-cashew butter (just that no one gets the idea I'm totally neglecting those peanuts), a pure cashew butter and one with cashew and chocolate (a perfect substitution for that nasty store bought Nutella).

I used fresh peanuts, it might be a bit more work to peel them, but it's also a good opportunity if you have some at home that need to be used up (we had some left from xmas). The most important thing while making your nut butter is a bit of patience. At first you have the feeling it will never get creamy, but then the magic happens and the oils of the nuts will help to get that perfect consistency. You can keep it in the fridge a long time, if you make sure there are no crumbs or other dirt in it.

Homemade nut butter in a jar

5G4A2758Nussbutter - 3 einfache Varianten

We love the nut butter as topping for our breakfast bowls, on bread, but you can also use it for soups or salad dressings (please don't use the chocolate one for that:-)).

5G4A2712 15G4A2711 1

And here are some easy snack ideas with them as well: dip your fruits in them, like apples, as spread on corn waffles with different toppings, or my favorite: as filling for dates topped with pomegranate seeds.

Nut butter with apple wedges, stuffed dates and a pancake, plated

5G4A29025G4A28935G4A2898

Have you ever tried to make your own nut butter? Or nut milk? I would love to hear your experience and your favorites. And if you haven't tried it yet, you will for sure not regret it, it's so easy and you will be surprised by the result. If you're in the mood for more homemade basics, do try my basic recipe for almond milk as a creamy base for breakfast bowls. For a crunchy topping my chocolate granola is wonderful alongside, and for a quick breakfast with a dollop of nut butter on top I love my chiapudding basic recipe.

Yours, Verena

TIPS

Verena's notes

A tip from my kitchen: bring a little patience to the blending – the mixture turns firm and crumbly first, but then the oils release and the butter gets creamy almost by itself. Take short breaks so the blender doesn't overheat. I always roast the nuts briefly, it makes the flavour so much more intense. Stored in the fridge, the nut butter keeps forever, as long as you scoop it out with a clean, dry spoon.

Three jars of homemade nut butter side by side

Nutbutter - 3 easy recipes

Homemade nut butter in 3 easy variations – roasted nuts blended until velvety, all vegan and without added sugar (except the chocolate one).

  • Course:Basics, Breakfast
Vegan

INGREDIENTS

Cashew-Peanut:

Cashew:

Cashew-chocolate:

INSTRUCTIONS

  1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees (356°F), add the nuts to a baking pan and bake for 10-15 minutes (keep an eye on them)

Cashew-Peanut

  1. Add the roasted nuts, salt and vanilla to a food processor or high speed blender and mix for a minimum of 10 minutes
  2. The mixture will form a lump at first, but just keep on mixing and after scrap the sides with a spatula from time to time and keep mixing
  3. The mixture will get soft and after 10-15 minutes you have a perfectly smooth nut butter

Cashew

  1. Add Cashew and salt to the mixer and process as described above

Cashew-chocolate

  1. Keep half of the cashew butter in the mixer, add the remaining ingredients and mix again until well combined
GOOD TO KNOW

Frequently asked questions

  • Kept in the fridge, nut butter lasts a very long time – often several weeks to months. The only thing that matters is that no crumbs, water or other impurities get into the jar. Always scoop it out with a clean, dry spoon.

  • That's completely normal. As you blend, the nuts are first ground into a firm, crumbly mass. If you keep going patiently, the natural oils in the nuts are released – and then the mixture suddenly softens and turns creamy all on its own. Scraping the sides down with a spatula helps.

  • A high-speed blender or a powerful food processor works best. Either one needs 10 to 15 minutes to bring the butter to a creamy consistency. Take short breaks so the machine doesn't overheat, and keep scraping the mixture back down from the sides.

  • Roasting isn't essential, but it makes a big difference. The nuts develop a more intense, nuttier flavour and release their oils more easily, so the butter turns creamy faster. 10 to 15 minutes at 180 °C (356°F) is enough – just keep an eye on them so they don't burn.

  • Yes. The pure cashew butter and the peanut-cashew version need no added sugar at all – the flavour of the roasted nuts is intense enough. Only the cashew-chocolate spread is sweetened with a little maple syrup, and you can adjust that to taste too.

How did you like this recipe?


Leave a comment

Never published.


No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts.

FOLLOW US

@frei_style on Instagram

Follow us for daily inspiration from our kitchen.

Instagram content blocked by your cookie settings.

Share this recipe

PIN IT

Pinterest

Three jars of homemade nut butter side by side
Save to Pinterest